"Where do you eat?" is never a question about restaurants
Published on
Have you ever paid close attention to how guests ask questions, not just what they ask? The close examination of the real purpose behind the question is to be found if you understand why certain questions, like “Where do you eat?” are posed the way they are.
What’s the difference between “Which restaurant do you recommend?” and “Where do you like to eat?” Can a receptionist, who most often hears these types of questions, even respond to it honestly?
The guest is asking the local where they actually go, on an ordinary evening, when nobody is watching, and they are not at work. It is a small question, yet a great deal is folded inside it. The guest is not looking for information they could easily find online. They are asking to be let in, to experience the city or a place as an insider, and to step immediately behind the veil of obvious tourist offers that don’t feel “real” or “authentic”. There’s a whole trend around people’s urge to feel “special”, not just like a tourist, and it is usually dressed up in slogans such as “Eat like a local”.
The answer a receptionist could offer, if being completely honest, would usually be of no use to the guest. They eat standing up in their own kitchen at half past eleven. They eat the staff meal at four in the afternoon, out of a bowl, in eight minutes. And they eat at the place near their flat with the strip lighting and the paper napkins, which has no reason on earth to interest a visitor from another continent.
What can the receptionist answer to that tricky question? Well, they name somewhere good, somewhere a little off the main square, somewhere that will let guests feel they were handed a special piece of information the other guests were not.
Guests wish to be “special”, “different” rather than a regular “tourist”
Think about how you behave in a city you do not know. You walk past the restaurants with laminated menus in six languages and photographs of the food. You are well aware that these photographs are addressed to you, and you would rather not be addressed, but you want to play a sort of treasure hunt, searching for the right restaurant. You are hunting for the place with locals inside and almost nothing written outside. You say you are looking for somewhere authentic, somewhere not touristy, somewhere the locals actually go.
We want to sit at the edge of somebody else’s ordinary evening and watch it happen without our arrival changing it. We want to be witnesses rather than customers, so we would have the privilege of observation, of blending in, of a sort of “spying on locals”. But the problem is we are trying to achieve that in places whose entire purpose is to have customers.
But why do we prefer to be witnesses rather than active participants in set-ups like restaurants?
A customer plays an active role, and they know they owe something to their host. On the other hand, a witness owes nothing to anyone, and it is quite appealing to think that the transaction becomes invisible. You get to feel you are there by welcome rather than by payment, which is why every moment that reminds a guest they are paying becomes a small rupture in that fantasy they want to be a part of.
The paradox is that the more skilfully a place performs its own non-commerciality, the more sophisticated its commerce actually is. The feeling of not being sold to is one of the most expensive products in hospitality, and one of the most profitable, if you know how to package it correctly.
It is an old desire, and a very human one, to seek “something real”. I would argue that the hospitality industry kind of cracked that code by setting up a theatre of “backstage” and bringing it to the front. Think how dining experiences have changed since the wall between the kitchen and the dining room came down. And that’s just one example — I’ve named many more of them in my previous article, “Hospitality is a theatre. Can you conjure an honest performance?”
The man who saw it coming as early as 1973!
Can you imagine that before social media became the stage of our daily performance, before reality TV was popular, and before marketing was “the thing,” someone was able to predict that tourists would increasingly want to become part of a hotel’s kitchen, uninterested in the buffet?
Dean MacCannell, an American sociologist who watched tourists, observed that travelers are not trying to see the front region. They are trying to get past it. Whatever is offered to them formally — the lobby, the dining room, the buffet, the guided route — registers instantly as the version arranged for visitors, and the visitor’s instinct is to look for the door at the back of it.
We tend to say that social media created a culture obsessed with access and exposure. The sequence suggests that the hunger was documented first, in a sociology journal, and an entire industry then arrived to feed it. Reality formats, vlogging, the making-of, the unboxing, the day-in-the-life — all of them are answers to a demand that a sociologist had already identified while watching tourists in the early 1970s. Which also means it will not pass. This is not a trend our industry can wait to fade out.
Tourist settings respond to that hunger by producing the feeling of having arrived backstage, whether or not anybody has arrived anywhere at all. Not through fraud, and usually not even deliberately, a place eventually figures out which of its rooms make visitors feel let in, and it starts to arrange those rooms. The arrangement works while the genuine back region moves one room further away. In this process, there is no end to seeking yet another closed door and repeating the staging that gives guests a feeling of arriving at a special “behind the scenes” space.
Dean MacCannell wrote his observations in a paper, “Staged Authenticity: Arrangements of Social Space in Tourist Settings,” and later expanded it into The Tourist: A New Theory of the Leisure Class.

Why are people asking to be let in?
Several reasons explain why backstage became so popular. Some have to do with trends, while others are based on sociology. Let’s unpack them.
“Guest” is a word with distance built into it.
A guest is by definition not of the house, not an insider, and thus not entitled to enjoy the benefits of locals and residents. The oldest promise in our business, to make yourself at home, is an instruction nobody can actually follow, since a guest can open the fridge in a friend’s kitchen and cannot open the fridge in yours. The gap between the phrase and the reality, which is that all relationships in hospitality are transactional, is where the whole appetite for “sneaking behind closed doors” lives.
Being or feeling special is relational.
It requires someone else not to be as special and chosen as you are. Room or service upgrades that hotels sell work solely because the room next door did not get one. The table by the window becomes even more desirable because there is a limited capacity of tables next to the window, and thus you have to be lucky or special to sit there.
Be aware not to over-sell the backstage.
The issue with access-as-insiderness is that the moment you standardize it, it stops delivering the feeling it was built to deliver. A behind-the-scenes tour offered to every guest is a scheduled activity. The same tour offered to one guest or a group of friends still feels like something special. Scaling such “insiders” activities is literally what kills the vibe. If you want to design your offers around what is going on behind closed doors, you’ll have to be innovative enough not to overdo it or over-sell it.
The endless quest for something real, unique, and human
Thinking about why we, as humans, are so nosy, and why we need to feel so special to be let backstage, made me wonder what it is all about. At first, I’d bet on curiosity, yet going back, MacCannell points to a different scenario.
He argues that modern life is experienced as fragmented, and that people come to feel their own existence is somehow not quite real. If your life doesn’t feel “real”, you end up searching for that “truly real” somewhere else. There’s a conviction that real life is happening somewhere else — in other people, other places, other communities that still have wholeness we have lost. Grass is always greener on the other side.
And tourism becomes the ritual we perform to find that “real” life, “real” world, “real” something. MacCannell compares it to pilgrimage: a structured journey to a site believed to hold reality, undertaken by people who feel short of it at home. Which means the desire to get backstage is a symptom of suspecting that one’s own life does not have a backstage worth being in.
That appetite is constant and will remain this way unless people change tremendously, which I wouldn’t bet on. What is changing are the stages and environments where this hunger for “something real” is performed, and where people watch people instead of the process of making something. Think shows such as Big Brother, or social media BeReal. It is all programming us to seek the same experience in physical life, and where else could this be more appealing than in the hospitality and travel industry?
All of this might have started when the chef became a character, and as a consequence, the kitchen became content. Anthony Bourdain’s Kitchen Confidential accidentally made the back region of a restaurant more interesting than the front. He didn’t romanticize the backstage; he told people it was dirtier, funnier, and more human than they imagined, and the audience loved him for his honesty and transparency. Then the format was industrialized into all sorts of Chef’s TV shows & later, Netflix series, which transformed chefs into modern stars. Not to start with how, at least us, in Western societies, have become increasingly demanding in wanting to know about every single ingredient in each dish we order. But that’s a debate for some other time.
Another thing worth mentioning is that people respond to evidence of a human being. Not effort in the abstract sense, nor a process itself, like preparing a meal. Underneath all of this, we actively seek proof that a person chose to do something for us, like a chef preparing a meal. We want to see the kitchen because it contains people performing their craft. I think this need will become even larger as humanoids partially replace some human labor.
Six stages where hospitality is performed
MacCannell’s contribution when observing what is a front stage and what is a back end mapped six positions along the spectrum. For the purpose of this article, and since I assume you need examples of how to do the backstage properly, I’ve collected several ideas for each of these six layers. Let’s take a closer look and see how they play out in the hospitality business.
Stage one — the plain front region
This one is straightforward and doesn’t require much philosophical thought to understand. Here everything is obviously arranged for visitors, which a traveler registers within seconds.
Examples: The reception desk, the lobby, the breakfast buffet, the welcome drink handed over on a tray.
Cost: cheap to build, cheap to run, entirely safe. Stage one is absolutely a must, since we read this space easily and expect it to be there. The error is believing that stage one alone is enough, which is how a property ends up lost in a traveler’s memory.
Stage two — the front region, decorated with backstage objects
Here you take objects that belong to the working part of the business and move them into the part where guests sit, purely as decoration. Nothing behind the scenes changes. The kitchen stays shut; you’ve simply borrowed its props for aesthetic reasons.
Examples:
Copper pans and hanging utensils mounted on a dining room wall, or chef’s knives in a display case, while the actual kitchen is behind a closed door twenty meters away.
Exposed brick or visible ductwork, which represent the building’s own structural guts, left uncovered (on purpose or out of ignorance).
A wall of wine bottles at the entrance that nobody ever serves from and are either empty or have been off for a long time.
Old farm tools screwed to the wall of a breakfast room, although local farmers have absolutely nothing to do with what is being served for breakfast.
A blackboard menu written out by hand every morning even though the menu has not changed in two years.
What a hotelier can do with it:
The examples we just met belong to the atmosphere, and I’m not saying that atmosphere is of no use at all. The mistake is describing it as authenticity in your marketing, because a guest who has seen four of these lobbies in a year doesn’t see any of it as unique. Use the atmospheric decoration to set a tone and let something much more “real” carry your actual claim about authenticity.
Cost: Cheap to build, cheap to maintain, and available to absolutely everyone, which is exactly the problem of generalistic ideas. After fifteen years of industrial-chic interiors, this type of decoration is close to exhausted, so stage two differentiates almost nobody.
Stage three — a front region built entirely to look like a back region
Now the whole space is designed around the premise you are somewhere you are not supposed to be. Nothing here was ever a working area. It was constructed from scratch and designed to feel like one.
Examples:
The speakeasy, which is a global bar category built on a fake back door — PDT in New York is entered through a telephone booth inside a hot dog shop. The hidden entrance is the product, and people seem to adore it.
A hotel breakfast room designed as a farmhouse kitchen, belonging to a farm that does not exist.
A tasting room built to resemble a working cellar, standing directly next to the actual working cellar.
A “chef’s table” positioned in the dining room and dressed to look like a kitchen pass.
Instagram post by @pdtnyc
What a hotelier can do with it:
Stage three works beautifully on one condition — the guest has to be in on the game. Nobody walking into a speakeasy believes they have discovered a secret; the pleasure is in the shared pretense. Build it, enjoy it, and never present it as the real thing. Don’t try to trick your guests into thinking that stage three is the representation of stage six.
Cost: Expensive to build and structurally fragile. The investment is in design, and it has to be well planned, because a half-convincing replica is worse than no replica.
Stage four — a genuine back region, opened to guests
This is a real working space, with visitors now inside it. Nothing new has been invented, but something that already existed has had its door taken off.
Examples:
The open kitchen, where the wall between preparation and dining is removed.
A chef’s table set inside the working kitchen rather than beside it.
Brewery and distillery tours, the cheese cave, or harvest days where guests actually pick.
A production bakery with a glass front onto the street.
Back-of-house tours. For example, the Park Hyatt Maldives walks paying guests past the industrial laundry machines, the diesel generators powering the island, the workshop where broken chairs get repaired, and the staff canteen. We saw this case in the previous article.
Real-life example, called “osmica”
One of the oldest versions of it comes from my home country, Slovenia. We call it “osmica” as the number eight. In 1784, a decree issued under Joseph II allowed farmers to sell their surplus wine, untaxed, directly from their homes for eight days a year. Eight is where the name comes from. Guests ate in the cellar or in the family’s own rooms, and the opening was announced by hanging an ivy branch where the road could see it, which is still how you find one today. Yet much later, for a long period of time, that tradition broke. “Osmice” ran in Primorska until 1943, disappeared entirely after the war, and was only revived in the 1980s. Today, a winemaker may open twice a year, for up to ten days at a time. This tradition represents a genuine back region: opened on a license, according to rules, for a fixed period, and reconstructed a generation after it was completely abandoned and almost forgotten.
What a hotelier can do with it:
Start smaller than you want to. Pick one process, one time slot, one member of staff who actually enjoys being watched; don’t force someone who hates this type of exposure into a front-person. Pick the process you are genuinely proud of rather than the one that is the most trendy or Instagrammable. And notice the warning built into the “Osmica”: the opening periods have been extending year after year, and some now run close to restaurants. That was never the initial intention, though.
Cost:
Inverted. Cheap to build, because you already own the kitchen, yet expensive to run, because the space must now be permanently presentable, permanently staffed to standard, and permanently safe to look at. Properties open a door because it appears to cost nothing and discover they have signed a daily obligation they didn’t count on.
Stage five — a genuine back region, tidied for occasional visits
This is the same real space you use for your work, but you’ve decided to provide occasional access into your “behind the scenes”. You prepare the space for special occasions, and anyone entering during that time understands it is a privilege to be invited behind closed doors. You don’t need to fake anything or make it more glamorous than it is; you are simply asked to make a space a slightly better version of itself for ninety minutes.
Examples:
The kitchen is deep-cleaned on the morning of the tour.
The farm is swept before the group arrives.
The staff canteen acquires a decent coffee machine the week the auditors come.
Personal mugs put in a cupboard, the broken chair wheeled out of shot, the newest team member told kindly not to mention the freezer.
What a hotelier can do with it:
Measure the time and effort it takes to prepare the space so it’s decent enough to let the visitor in. How long does it take between deciding a guest may see this space and the space actually being ready to be seen? That number is one of the most honest diagnostics in your building.
Stage six — the back region as it is when nobody is coming
That is the only real thing. Nobody has prepared anything, nobody is selling tickets to it, and by MacCannell’s definition the tourist never reaches it — because the moment they do, it becomes stage five.
Examples:
Tuesday afternoon in February. Shutters half down. A supplier has failed, one person is off sick, and whoever is on shift has been there since seven and is eating standing up.
The staff room at four o’clock, when it is shift time and one half of the personnel is in a rush to work, while the other half can’t wait to get home.
What a hotelier can do with it:
This is where the money should actually go, if you want your staff to feel well. Stage six is the version your staff lives in for most of the year. It decides everything above it — a property in poor shape here can still run a perfectly good stage two, yet will struggle badly the moment it opens a kitchen, and will become a disaster the first time a guest opens the wrong door looking for the toilet.
Cost: Staging costs you again every season. Fixing stage six costs you once.

Takeaways for hoteliers
The search for authenticity is structurally destined to be answered with staging. Why? Because observation changes what is observed. Ever heard of the Hawthorne effect, where factory workers’ productivity changed simply because they knew they were being studied? The moment a back region is offered to a guest, it begins climbing the ladder. There is no escape route through sincerity, effort, or good intentions.
When it comes to staging, three responses are available to you.
Declare the staging.
Stop calling staged things authentic and call them what they are. The speakeasy in New York proves this works: the game is shared, the pleasure is in the game, and nobody is lied to. A themed property that owns its theming stands on firmer ground than a neutral one claiming to be real.
Close the gap.
Work so that stage five requires almost no tidying, which means investing in stage six. This is a slower and more expensive strategy, yet it pays off. Closing that gap means shrinking the distance until almost no preparation is required — until any door can be opened at any hour without warning, and nothing needs to be moved out of sight first. Think about the difference between tidying before visitors arrive and living in a house that is already tidy. The first is a performance you have to repeat forever, and it costs you every single time. The second costs more at the start and then stops costing, because you have changed the thing itself rather than its appearance.
Decline to open.
Keep the back region closed and first put effort in the front regions. This still obviously is a legitimate strategy. Not every property owes its guests access to its kitchen, and if you don’t feel like inviting people to your sofa, you don’t need to.
Let’s end where we started.
Go back to the receptionist and the question she gets asked every day. “Where do you eat?” She could tell the truth, and say: “I eat at the place near my flat that has terrible lighting and the best fish in the city, and you would probably hate it.” And some guests — the ones actually asking to be let in rather than asking for a recommendation — would be delighted, because that answer is unmistakably real and could not have come from anywhere else.
The reason the receptionist usually doesn’t answer honestly is that it’s a small act of exposure, and nobody has told her it is allowed. So, is this type of backstage exposure allowed at your hotel?